Rahul Sharma's AP Govt Blog 1.2

We conservatives champion local power. So we must respect the rights of “blue” cities.

The two sides of the argument over sanctuary cities are the Trump Administration and the residents of the cities. The Trump Administration wants to "crack down" on the sanctuary cities. The disagreements about how to be governed are growing. 
In defense of liberalism, Chesterton came up with “distributism,” which aimed for decision-making to be taken care of at local levels. This devolution will bring power back to the states. This devolution essentially meant local control of government, with less interference from the federal government. Devolution of powers is usually associated with conservatives.
Nowadays, however, liberals would probably support devolution. When thinking of our current president, it seems logical to devolve and bring power back to the states and away from him.
The author uses abortion to bring up the desires of the two groups. Both want a federal law to reflect their views. However, with a federal law forcing everyone to act in one way is a recipe for disaster. The main problem with federalism is the voting process. The author states that Millions of voters condition their entire vote on whom a candidate will appoint to the Supreme Court, and not much else matters.
The unwillingness to give up powers is what prevents local governments from solving more questions locally. Also, many activists prefer federal laws, so that their views will be enforced everywhere.
A large proportion of the conservatives are older people, and it is very unlikely that they will give up Social Security and medicare. And, if the people do not like the rules, they are free to leave the state, and those who remain agree with the law and will vote for its continuation.
If states were able to have more varied policies, policies would probably vary greatly from state to state, reflecting what is best for the particular state, without regards to the national needs.
The author argue that conservatives should end their opposition to sanctuary cities, because as long as conservatives support state preemption of localities whenever localities embrace liberal causes, they will have no credibility in advocating for devolution of powers on other matters.
True federalism is painful because it allows other people around us to do things we think are terrible, and we can do nothing about it.
If more local governments had more control over policy, I believe the states will abuse powers until eventually, the states will lose a sense of national unity and revert to a confederacy.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Rahul Sharma's AP Govt Blog 2.1

Revolving Door: About half of retiring senators and a third of retiring House members register as lobbyists  7th period         Members of the Senate are more likely to become lobbyists with 87% of retiring Senators becoming lobbyists, compared to the 78% of retiring House Representatives becoming lobbyists.  Congressmen were less likely to become lobbyists in the 1970s and 1980s because  the lobbying industry was not nearly as big then. The real growth of lucrative Washington lobbying started in the 1990s  This research likely underestimate the revolving door due to many  members preferring to not  register , but still do  work that looks very much like lobbying.  I think committee chairmen are more likely to become lobbyists because of the connections and valuable information they have.  The author mentions that registration requirements were "looser" back in the day, meaning that they are stricter now. These strict...
Read more

Rahul Sharma's AP Govt Blog 3.3

Quick Shut Down  Congress failing to pass a new  government funding  law before the old one expired led to the government shutdown.  In a shutdown,  Military and law enforcement activities continue.  Social Security  checks still go out. Air traffic controllers still go to work.  However, activities the government has deemed “nonessential” stop.  One point of potential leverage Democrats had over the Republicans is that Democratic votes are needed to fund the government. So, activists argued that Democrats shouldn’t vote for any government funding bill without a DACA deal.  Some Democrats were eager to end the shut down quickly because  keeping the government shut down on behalf of unauthorized immigrants — even the DREAMers — is a political loser. Furthermore, many Democratic senators are facing tough reelections in red states this year and fear being tagged as extremists.   In the funding agreement, the Children's He...
Read more

Rahul Sharma's AP Govt Blog 3.5

How the 9th Circuit became conservatives’ least favorite court The district court is a trial court within the Ninth Circuit; the appellate court is one step higher on the ladder and oversees all individual districts.  The 9th Circuit has long been  stereotyped as a liberal outlier , prone to left-wing rulings that are frequently reversed by the Supreme Court on appeal.  The Court’s reputation arguably derives from its transformation under President Jimmy Carter. While Carter was the only the fourth president to make no appointments to the Supreme Court, he did appoint 15 people to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, and  Carter appointed some of the most liberal judges ever, to any court.  Stephen Reinhardt wrote the Ninth Circuit’s opinion striking down California’s same-sex marriage ban Proposition 8 in 2012, ruled that the Second Amendment doesn’t recognize an individual right to bear arms, and argued that bans on assisted suicide ...
Read more